You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own truths


*This article has been updated for relevance, coz sh*t is getting crazy out here*

In the heavy backlash that followed Toni Gonzaga for her glowing endorsement of the Marcoses at a kickoff rally, supporters of both personalities have come out to defend their idols, all arguing the same thing: ‘Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion.’

It is the same argument put forth when Toni had her interview with Bongbong Marcos. Their supporters argue that the criticism hounding the actress is proof of a skewed version of democracy. They accuse critics of becoming dictators themselves, policing only a specific point of view (‘the promotion was in bad taste’) while canceling others.

They then circle back to their main argument, ‘Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.’

opinion, <b> You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own truths </b>

Opinions are not made equal

In an article from The Conversationist, philosophy professor Patrick Stokes cites that ‘everybody has an opinion’ is an argument often used to defend a belief that should have been long since abandoned.

Stokes, who teaches at Deakin University in Australia, says that people who use this statement often use it to justify saying whatever they like. In some ways, they guilt trip those who continue to argue as somehow being disrespectful.

Depending on the context, ‘everybody has an opinion’ can be harmless. Stokes uses ice cream flavors as an example. It would be silly to label someone as ‘wrong’ if they prefer strawberry over chocolate. Or to call them ‘ignorant’ if they disagree.

But opinions exist in all forms, from your preferred taste of ice cream, to your stances on technology, science, and in this case, politics. In the case of the last three, opinions are given more weight and meaning.

These opinions are open to discourse because they will a) answer to well-established facts and b) influence the lives of many people. It would be sillier to think that ‘strawberry is better than chocolate’ deserves to be as disputed as ‘vaccines are a scam’, ‘COVID-19 is not real’, or that ‘Marcos did nothing wrong’.

The rights of BBM and Toni

BBM is free to shout to the high heavens that his father was a saint, that the well-documented Martial Law victims were wrong, and that the billions of ill-gotten wealth, portions of which have since been recovered, were nothing more than imaginary figures.

The same goes for Toni and ‘Toni Talks’. Toni is free to guest whoever she wants on her show, a decision she has publicly made. It’s her channel, after all. She can also endorse any candidate she wishes, since it is her civil right to do so.

So if their supporters’ argument of ‘everybody has an opinion’ means that the two are free to say whatever they want to say, then yes, they are correct on a surface level.

opinion, <b> You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own truths </b>

But to ask the general public, those who still possess some common sense, to readily accept and respect the lies being spewed for the sake of ‘democracy’, then that is not possible. It is also everyone else’s right to call you out on your BS.

This is because, in the face of facts backed by reputable journalists, historians, and other fact-checking bodies, BBM and Toni’s glamorization of the Marcos regime does not hold up. There is extensive proof that Marcos Sr. was a plunderer, a dictator, who in no way deserves to be pictured as an adorable teddy bear by his son and his followers.

Sure, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but not to their own truths. And if your opinion falters in the face of facts, and yet you still persist, your opinion then becomes a delusion.

To argue against this romanticization is not being disrespectful or being a dictator. It’s about being an empathetic human being, who recognizes that all of the sacrifices made years ago shouldn’t be devalued and forgotten.

You also need not have been born in a specific era to know that lying, killing, and stealing are bad. That is basic common sense.

Respect is earned, not given

The concept of absolute opinions is something we hope the public will realize someday.

You are free to make your stance, fall for the Marcos propaganda, and believe pseudo-experts from Tiktok and Youtube instead of trusted sources. You are welcome to be delusional in private, but don’t expect people to ‘respect your opinion’ if you go public.

After all, respect is earned, not given. And it is only human nature to favor those who are for prosperity and progress, not the ones who support proven thieves, liars, or murderers.

opinion, <b> You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own truths </b>
Martial law victims – ABS-CBN News

Must Read